ManageWP is strongest at checking and backing up the site itself. MainWP is strongest at one flat price for unlimited sites. Both run updates on a schedule you set.
ManageWP is a cloud dashboard that backs up the site and checks each update itself. MainWP is a self-hosted dashboard an agency runs on its own site, at one flat price for unlimited sites. Both run updates on a schedule you set, and on both the alert comes to you. NoDrama is a service that runs the updates and responds, and it leaves hosting with you.
TL;DR
How we compared
We compared ManageWP and MainWP against the same twenty-seven attributes, grouped into scope of work, updates, recovery, work capacity, and commercial terms. The attribute set was fixed before we looked at either product.
Every ManageWP and MainWP figure comes from that vendor’s own pages and documentation, read on 12 October 2026 and rechecked on 13 October 2026. NoDrama’s come from its own pricing page, read on 2 September 2026 and rechecked on 9 October 2026. Where a vendor does not state something on its own site, the cell reads “Not published” rather than “No”. Those are different claims.
NoDrama is ours, and it sits in every table on the same terms as the other two. Where it loses a row, the table says so. No figure on this page comes from a review site, a forum thread or a rival’s comparison page.
Read side by side, ManageWP and MainWP differ on where the dashboard lives and how it is billed, and agree on everything after the alert: on both, the uptime alert comes to you, the fix the automation cannot make is yours, and neither publishes a support response clock.
Each product in a nutshell
ManageWP
ManageWP is a cloud dashboard for running many WordPress sites from one screen. Its core is free for unlimited sites, and paid features are per-site add-ons or flat-fee bundles for up to 100 sites. It runs updates manually or on a schedule you set, sends alerts, and you fix what breaks.
What it does: scheduled updates · Safe Updates · premium Backup add-on · Clone & Migrate · uptime monitoring every 60 seconds (paid add-on) · Security Check · Automated Security Check · Vulnerability Protection · Client Reports · Advanced Client Reports · Link Monitor.
- Safe Updates covers plugins, themes and core: it pauses if the page isn’t 200 OK and rolls back automatically on a 4xx or 5xx.
- With the premium Backup add-on, it takes a full restore point before each update and a before-and-after screenshot of one chosen page.
- Backups sit off-site in a US or EU data center, your choice per site, kept 90 days on free and premium.
- No minimum commitment: billing is monthly on usage, with no contracts and no termination penalty.
- With its paid uptime add-on, the site is checked every 60 seconds, with alerts by email, SMS or Slack.
- It is a tool: alerts come to you, and you fix what breaks.
- The free tier backs up monthly only. Safe Updates and more frequent backups need the premium Backup add-on.
- There is no staging.
- Cleanup is not published, and no support response clock is published.
- What you keep on exit is not published, and neither is an independent second backup copy.
MainWP
MainWP is a self-hosted, open-source dashboard that installs on your own WordPress site. Essentials is free, Pro unlocks 30+ add-ons, and both cover unlimited sites. You host the dashboard and set up the updates: one click, or automatic for items you mark Trusted.
What it does: one-click or automatic (Trusted) core, plugin and theme updates · automatic rollback of a failed plugin or theme update · Regression Testing (Pro) · staging site creation (Pro) · child site cloning (Pro) · automatic client reports (Pro) · built-in uptime monitoring · API Backups through your host, or backup plugin add-ons · scanner integrations with Sucuri, Security Ninja, Wordfence, Jetpack Scan, Virusdie and the NVD vulnerability scanner · 30+ add-ons on Pro.
- One flat Pro price covers unlimited sites.
- It is self-hosted and open source, so the dashboard runs on your own site.
- Items marked Trusted update automatically, one to three times a day from a start time you set.
- A failed plugin or theme update rolls back automatically (MainWP 5.1+, WordPress 6.3+).
- Uptime monitoring is built in and free, with email alerts.
- It is a tool: you host the dashboard and set up the updates, and the dashboard is one more WordPress site to keep current.
- Backups run through a backup plugin or your host’s API, so frequency, retention and storage depend on what you connect.
- Security is scanning only, and no cleanup is published.
- Staging, client reports and Regression Testing are Pro only.
- Support is community-based on free and priority tickets on Pro, with no clock published.
NoDrama
NoDrama is a maintenance-only service. Hosting stays with you, and there is nothing for you to operate. We keep WordPress, plugins and themes current and start work when the site goes down.
What it does: WordPress core, plugins and themes kept current · risky updates flagged before we run them · key pages photographed before and after every update · backups every day, every 12 hours or every change, by tier · 90 days off-site, with roll back to any day in the 90 · a second copy held by another company · malware scan every 12 hours, edge firewall, DDoS and bot protection, known holes blocked, 2FA and login lockout · checked every minute · broken-looking pages spotted · a monthly report · migration and setup handled.
- We run the updates, and risky ones are flagged before we run them.
- Key pages are photographed before and after every update.
- Backups run as often as every change, kept 90 days off-site, with a second copy held by another company.
- The site is checked every minute, and when it is down or hacked we start within 4, 2 or 1 hours by tier.
- Migration and setup are handled, and everything is handed back when you leave, including the latest off-site backup.
- There is no hosting. Your site stays with your host.
- There is no free tier.
- On monthly billing, hack cleanups and setup are charged. Both are free on yearly.
- Before-and-after checks and automatic rollback are not unique to us. ManageWP’s premium Backup add-on screenshots one chosen page, MainWP’s Pro Regression Testing compares chosen pages, and both roll back a failed update.
- If you already run your own updates, you pay for updates you do not need.
MainWP vs ManageWP, group by group
ManageWP figures come from managewp.com/pricing, its Backup, Safe Updates and Uptime Monitor feature pages, and its guide to automatic updates. MainWP figures come from mainwp.com, its signup page and its documentation. Both were read on 12 October 2026 and rechecked on 13 October 2026.
Scope of work
Neither dashboard does the work around the updates. Both run them on a schedule once you set one up, and on both you answer the alert and fix what an automatic rollback does not. MainWP adds hosting and maintaining the dashboard itself, so ManageWP asks less of you here. NoDrama is maintenance-only: we run the updates, and hosting stays with you.
| Capability | ManageWP | MainWP | NoDrama |
|---|---|---|---|
| Class | Self-serve management dashboard (cloud) | Self-serve management dashboard (self-hosted, open source) | Maintenance-only |
| Hosting | No hosting. Sites stay with their host | No hosting. Dashboard installs on your own WordPress site | Separate, stays with you |
| What you still do yourself | Everything. The tool runs updates and sends alerts; you do the work and fix what breaks | Everything, plus hosting and maintaining the dashboard itself | Keep your hosting. Updates, backups and monitoring are run for you |
Every table lists ManageWP first, MainWP second and NoDrama third, the order the page introduces them. The order carries no verdict.
MainWP’s dashboard is a WordPress site of its own. Which means one more install to update, back up and keep online before any client site gets attention.
Updates
This group is close. Both run updates on a schedule and can roll back a failed one automatically, ManageWP with its premium Backup add-on. ManageWP also takes a full restore point first and screenshots one chosen page. MainWP’s Pro add-ons add staging and Regression Testing, which compares chosen pages’ HTML rather than screenshots.
NoDrama photographs key pages before and after every update, flags risky ones first, and runs the update itself.
| Capability | ManageWP | MainWP | NoDrama |
|---|---|---|---|
| Staging-tested | No staging. Safe Updates pauses if the page isn’t 200 OK and rolls back automatically on a 4xx or 5xx | Staging site creation is a Pro feature. No staging on free. A failed plugin or theme update rolls back automatically (MainWP 5.1+, WordPress 6.3+) | No. Key pages checked before and after each update, with rollback. |
| Cadence | You set the day and time; selected plugins and themes then update automatically, as regular or Safe Updates. Scheduling tier not stated on the pricing page | Automatic for items marked Trusted, once, twice or three times a day from a start time you set. Everything else you run | Every plugin, theme and core update, run by NoDrama |
| Staging on which tier | Pro only | No staging. Updates run on the live site | |
| WordPress core and PHP updates | Core updates from the dashboard, free tier. Safe Updates covers core, with the premium Backup add-on. PHP updates not published | Core updates in one click across all sites, or automatic if marked Trusted. PHP updates not published | WordPress core kept current, all plans. PHP updates not published |
| Plugin and theme updates | Yes, free tier. Manual or scheduled | Yes, one click across all sites, or automatic if marked Trusted | Yes, all plans. We run them |
| Pre-update backup or snapshot | Full restore point before each update, with the premium Backup add-on | Not published. Depends on the backup plugin you connect | Covered by the backup schedule |
| Risky updates flagged before they run | Yes, flagged before we run them |
ManageWP has no staging and checks the live page instead. MainWP offers staging on Pro, and leaves the backup before an update to whatever you connected.
Both run updates on a schedule once you set one up. Which means the automation is yours to configure, and anything it cannot roll back is yours to fix.
Recovery
ManageWP wins this group. Backups are built in, kept 90 days and held off-site in a data center you choose. MainWP backs up through a backup plugin add-on or free API Backups through your host, so frequency, retention and storage depend on what you connect. Neither publishes a cleanup service or an independent second copy.
NoDrama backs up as often as every change and keeps 90 days off-site. A second copy is held by another company. Hack cleanups are included on yearly billing.
| Capability | ManageWP | MainWP | NoDrama |
|---|---|---|---|
| Backup frequency | Monthly on free. Weekly, daily, hourly and on-demand with premium Backup | Set by you: a backup plugin add-on (UpdraftPlus, BackWPup and others), or free API Backups run through your host (cPanel, Plesk, Kinsta, Cloudways, GridPane, Vultr, DigitalOcean, Linode) | Every day, every 12 hours or every change, by plan |
| Retention | 90 days, free and premium | Depends on the backup plugin or host; not set by MainWP | 90 days off-site, roll back to any day in the 90 |
| Cleanup scope | Not published. Scanning only | Hack cleanups included on yearly billing, charged by the hour on monthly | |
| Off-site storage | Yes, US or EU data center, your choice per site | Depends on the backup plugin or host | Yes, off-site |
| Security cover included, and what | Security Check free. Automated Security Check and Vulnerability Protection as paid add-ons. Cleanup not published | Scanner integrations: Sucuri, Security Ninja, Wordfence, Jetpack Scan, Virusdie, NVD vulnerability scanner. Scanning only, no cleanup published | Malware scan every 12 hours, edge firewall, DDoS and bot protection, known holes blocked, 2FA and login lockout, spam blocked on forms and login, all plans |
| Second copy held independently of host and vendor | Yes, a second copy held by another company |
ManageWP’s free tier backs up monthly. More frequent backups need the premium Backup add-on.
On MainWP, the backup belongs to the plugin or host you connect. Which means retention, storage and restore depend on that choice, not on MainWP.
Work capacity
Neither sells any hands-on time. Both are software only, and you do the work. NoDrama sells no fixed minutes. It takes on one, two or three small jobs at once, depending on the plan.
| Capability | ManageWP | MainWP | NoDrama |
|---|---|---|---|
| Work capacity: minutes, hours or jobs at once | None. Software only; you do the work | None. Software only; you do the work | No minutes sold. One, two or three small jobs at once, by plan |
Commercial terms
MainWP wins this group for anyone running many sites. One flat Pro price covers unlimited sites, and because MainWP is self-hosted and open source, the dashboard runs on your own site. ManageWP’s flat-fee bundles cover up to 100 sites each. A year of the cheapest one still costs more than a year of MainWP Pro.
ManageWP has no contract and no termination penalty, and does not publish what you keep on exit.
On both, the uptime alert goes to you and no support clock is published. NoDrama checks the site every minute, starts within 4, 2 or 1 hours by tier when it is down or hacked, and hands everything back when you leave.
| Capability | ManageWP | MainWP | NoDrama |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feature flatness | Free core for unlimited sites. Paid features are per-site add-ons | Free Essentials vs Pro; Pro unlocks 30+ add-ons. Unlimited sites on both | Every feature on every plan. Plans differ on backup frequency, response time, jobs at once and how often a restore is tested |
| Minimum commitment | None. Billed monthly on usage, no contracts, no termination penalty | None on monthly. 30-day money-back guarantee | None on monthly. Cancel anytime; yearly runs to the end of the paid year |
| Ownership on exit | Self-hosted and open source; the dashboard runs on your own site | Everything handed back when you leave, including the latest off-site backup | |
| Support response commitment | No clock published | Community support on free, priority tickets on Pro. No clock published | Down or hacked: 4, 2 or 1 hours by plan |
| Uptime monitoring and who responds | Every 60 seconds, paid add-on or bundle. Alerts you by email, SMS or Slack; you respond | Built in, free: HTTP(s), ping or keyword checks every 5 minutes to 24 hours (default 60 minutes), email alerts. Optional Uptime Robot, NodePing, Site24x7 or Better Uptime integrations. You respond | Checked every minute; NoDrama responds |
| Monthly report of work performed | Client Reports free; Advanced Client Reports paid add-on | Automatic client reports, Pro | Yes, a dated monthly report |
| Broken pages spotted between updates | Not published. Link Monitor add-on checks broken links | Yes, broken-looking pages spotted | |
| Migration and setup handled | Clone & Migrate tool with premium Backup; you run it | Child site cloning, Pro; you run it | Yes. Free on yearly billing, a one-time fee on monthly |
Client reports are free on ManageWP and a Pro feature on MainWP. Both offer a migration tool, and on both, you run it.
ManageWP leads Recovery, and Updates is close. MainWP leads Commercial terms, and its uptime monitoring is free where ManageWP’s is a paid add-on. Scope of work and work capacity show what the two share: the setup, the alert and the fix stay with you.
Can you run either alongside NoDrama?
Can you keep ManageWP alongside NoDrama?
No
No, not for updates. ManageWP runs updates manually or on a schedule, and NoDrama keeps WordPress, plugins and themes current, so running both means two parties updating one site.
Can you keep MainWP alongside NoDrama?
No
No, not for updates. MainWP’s Trusted auto-updates would run alongside ours. An agency already running MainWP across its client sites is MainWP’s buyer, and MainWP is the right tool for it.
Who should choose what
Choose ManageWP if you want backups and a check on each update built in, without hosting a dashboard, and you would rather pay per site, or per bundle of up to 100 sites, for the features you use.
Choose MainWP if you are an agency that owns its stack: one flat price for unlimited sites, self-hosted, open source, and a team that sets up and watches the updates.
Choose NoDrama if you run a business site and nobody in-house owns the update cycle, or you supply UK central government under Cyber Essentials and patching runs on a fourteen-day clock. Agencies with many client sites, and anyone running their own updates, are better served by a dashboard.
Choose neither if the site changes a few times a year and a day offline costs nothing. Whether a site like that needs monthly maintenance at all is a fair question to settle first.
At agency scale MainWP stays the cheaper dashboard: Pro covers unlimited sites for $199/yr, less than twelve months of ManageWP’s cheapest bundle.
If you want a dashboard to run the updates yourself, either one is cheaper and you should buy it. NoDrama costs more because we run the updates, check the pages and respond when the site goes down. Hack cleanups are included on yearly billing and $50 an hour on monthly, and setup is $149 one-time on monthly and free on yearly.
NoDrama is the recommended buy for an owner-operator who came here about to take on a dashboard and every update that comes with it. On ManageWP and MainWP alike, the setup, the alert and the fix stay with you.
We run the updates and photograph key pages before and after. We back up as often as every change, with a second copy held by another company, check the site every minute, and start within 4, 2 or 1 hours when it is down. We do not host the site, and there is no free tier. See the three plans and what each covers.
How to switch
Leaving either dashboard means removing it from the dashboard and then removing the plugin it put on each site. Set up whatever replaces it first, so the site is never without backups or uptime checks.
Leaving ManageWP
- 01Set up the replacement’s backups and uptime checks, and confirm the first backup has run.
- 02Take a fresh backup of the site that you hold outside ManageWP.
- 03In ManageWP, open the site, go to its options under General, and choose Remove Website.
- 04On the site itself, go to Plugins, then deactivate and delete the ManageWP Worker plugin.
Leaving MainWP
- 01Set up the replacement’s backups and uptime checks, and confirm the first backup has run.
- 02Check where your existing backups are stored. MainWP backs up through the plugin or host you connected, so the copies sit wherever that plugin or host keeps them.
- 03In your dashboard, go to MainWP > Sites > Manage Sites and choose Remove for the site.
- 04On the site itself, check that MainWP Child is deactivated, then delete it. MainWP’s own documentation says removing a site deletes its record from the dashboard, not the website, and that MainWP attempts to deactivate MainWP Child but you may need to do it by hand.
Do not delete the old tool’s backups until the new setup has completed at least one backup of its own.
How to choose a WordPress maintenance company sets out what to check before you sign.